Saturday, February 7, 2009

Task 2- ESL Website Evaluation

TASK 2: ESL WEBSITE EVALUATION

1. What does the application attempt to “teach”?
The application of Activities For ESL Students (http://a4esl.org/) attempts to teach the second language learners to learn and improve their English language skills. This application touches 3 main topics, which are grammar, vocabulary and crossword puzzle.
Firstly, the correct usage of grammar is very important in learning English language hence, this website introduced the ‘grammar’ as the first topic to be learned by the students. According to Thornburry (1999) grammar can be defined as ‘The study of what forms (or structure) are possible in a language and it is the rule of the language that gives guides to the speakers to use the language correctly and properly’. So, without proper usage of grammar rules the learners will not understand the language and will face many difficulties in using the target language. In this website, the topic of grammar is divided into 4 levels, which are easy, medium, difficult and quizzes (places). Every level has lists of activities and exercises that the students can use in learning the language. For example, for the easy level (http://a4esl.org/a/g.html), there are 2 stages, which the learners should go through and the first stage is a warm-up activities and the second stage consists more specific elements such as articles, plural, prepositions, pronouns, verbs and word forms. The learning of grammar from this site will enhance the skills of the learners in using the correct and proper English language structures. Secondly, the topic of vocabulary also comprises of 4 levels, which are easy, easy with pictures, medium and difficult. For example, for the medium level (http://a4esl.org/a/v3.html), there are tons of activities and quizzes that the learners can use and practice to increase their numbers of vocabularies in acquiring the English language hence, they will learn new words and be able to use those words in practicing the language in their daily lives. Thirdly, the crossword puzzle section gives enjoyment to the learners in learning the language. There are 2 levels for this section, which are easy and not so easy. Most of people love to play with puzzle because it can triggers their minds to challenge themselves in completing the puzzle, therefore this website provide puzzles in teaching the learners the target language. For example, for the easy level (http://iteslj.org/cw/), there are 2 stages that the learners can choose and each stage has lists of crossword puzzles. It is very interesting and fun to play with. All in all, all the 3 major topics in this website are mediums for the learners to learn the English language hence, improve their skills for this target language.

2. What sorts of things is the application user expected to do with regards to learning the content?
For this application (Activities For ESL Students), apart from learning the elements of learning the language, the users are expected to use and answer the quizzes, tests, exercises and puzzles. By doing all these 4 elements, the learners will gain more knowledge on the target language thus improve their skills in the language. For example, after the learners already gone through all the 3 levels (easy, medium, difficult) for the topic of grammar, they can test their performances by answering the quiz specifically about places (http://a4esl.org/a/g7.html). There are numbers of grammar quizzes with different topics and genres that the learners can choose to test their ability in learning the grammar component for English language. Therefore, this application not only teach the learners but also give them the experience on how to face with structured test hence able to know their abilities in acquiring the language.

3. What sort of computer skills is the application users expected to have in order to operate/access/use the application?
This application (Activities For ESL Students), is very easy to operate. Only basic computer skills are required in order to operate this application such as the used of ‘mouse’ to choose and ‘click’ the correct answers for the exercises and quizzes, and the skill of typing for the crossword puzzle section. All the exercises, quizzes and tests are in Multiple-Choice Question (MCQ). For instance, the grammar exercise for medium level (http://a4esl.org/q/h/vm/titanic.html), consists of several questions in MCQ format and therefore, the learners are only required to click the correct answer and check the result at the end of the section. There are no complicated skills that need to be put on to use those sections (quizzes, tests, exercises). The learners need to have the skill of typing in order to play with the crossword puzzle. For instance, the crossword puzzle for the easy level (http://iteslj.org/cw/1/vm-xmas.html), needs only clicking and typing at the puzzle. But it is very different from typing an essay hence, typing the words for the puzzle is so simple and easy. Thus, there is no need to worry much in using the application as only basic computer skills are needed in accessing this ESL website.

4. While you are “playing”/ “accessing”/ “assessing” the application, does it remind you of anything you do in the classroom, or with a teacher, or with a fellow classmate, or in self-study?
It is indeed reminds me the process of learning the language in a classroom with the classmates with the assistant from the teacher and also during the self-study. A lot of drills and practices been thrown to the students during the language learning in school. After the tutoring session with the teacher finished there is going to be massive of exercises according to the topic. This method is used to make sure the students understand the certain topics hence, the teacher can evaluate the students’ performances in acquiring the language. This way of learning the target language is similar to this application (Activities For ESL Students). Each main topic of grammar, vocabulary and crossword puzzle has tons of drills and exercise for the learners to try on so that they can learn from it. They might do some mistakes but from they learn best from it. They will try to improve and at the end the will be able to master the language after several challenges from finishing all the language drills. For example, the exercise from vocabulary topic for difficult level (http://a4esl.org/q/h/dt/ho16.html), shows the sample of a drill in learning the language. Therefore, this application is just as the same as the one that we always experienced during the school period where drills and practices are very important through out the process of learning the target language.

5. Can you pinpoint some theories of language learning and/or teaching underlying the application?
This website applies The Silent Way method. According to Gattegno (1972), The Silent Way method can be called as “Discovering learning”. In this method, the learners discover the knowledge independently and this will build the learners sense of autonomy and responsibility while discovering the new knowledge regarding the language. For instance, the learners can use this application without the guide of the teacher to learn the target language. They can choose any topic within this application (grammar, vocabulary, crossword puzzle), and they can try to use it independently with all the exercises and tests provided in the application. If the learners chose to complete the exercise for grammar topic for easy level (http://a4esl.org/q/h/mc006-ck.html) they can answer the questions and find the correct answers independently without the help of the teacher. In this way, the learners will know their mistakes and they can improve themselves by searching the answers on their own. According to Nunan (1989), explained the theory of The Silent Way method, as “Functional vocabulary and core structure are key to the spirit of the language”. We can see that this application is very concern on the elements of grammar and vocabulary. Therefore, there is no doubt that this application uses The Silent Way method in teaching the English language to the learners.

6. How well is the constructivist theory of learning applied to the chosen website?
According to the constructivist theory by Carl Rogers (1983), “Learning how to learn is more important than being taught something from the “superior” vantage point of a teacher who unilaterally decides what shall be taught”. Therefore, this theory very well applied to this application as the learners learn independently in using this application to learn English language and experience it by themselves without getting no orders from the teacher. By using this application, the learners can use and try all the exercises, quizzes and tests to improve their language skills hence, learn the mistakes from it. They will try to make less mistakes step by step and build up their skills through out the process of learning the language. They will realize their own mistakes and try to improve their errors so they managed to master the language independently. Through out the process they will know what is the best for them and from here they are learning how to learn. Sometimes, learners do not like to do what they are been asked to do. Thus, this is one of the ways for them to learn the language freedomly by using this application.

7. In 1980s and early 1990s, there was a major debate on ‘whether the computer was “master” of or “slave” to the learning process (Higgins and Johns, 1984). In relation to your evaluation – was the computer a replacement for teachers, or merely an obedient servant to students?
In my opinion, computer is a tool for the teachers and the students to upgrade language-learning process. The computer is not a replacement for teachers and also not the servant to the students. Firstly, the students cannot rely on the computer alone. They need teachers to guide them in learning the language. The role of a teacher is very important in teaching the students to master the target language. Excellent teachers will maneuver their students to the right way and manage to instill the love of the language inside the hearts of the students. The computers cannot make the students love the language but the teachers can. The computers do not have feelings like the teachers do hence, the computers cannot touch the soul of the students. With the ‘magical’ approach by the teachers, the students will gain their interests in learning and acquiring the language. The teachers are able to give detail explanations to the students while the computers are very rigid. Secondly, the computers are not the servants for the students as the learning process does not revolve around the usage of technology. The learning process will be very dull and monotonous if the students used only computers as their tool to learn the language. Interactions between friends and teachers will make the learning livelier thus, improve the communication skills with each other. The students can learn the language through reading books and magazines, and communicate with other people by using the target language. They still can survive even if the computers are not their obedient servants. Therefore, the computer is neither a replacement for the teachers nor the slave for the students. But the teachers and the students can use the computer as a tool to learn the target language as to make the learning process more fun and enjoyable.

8. Would you like to use the application yourself in your future work?
Yes, I would definitely use this application in my future work because of these 2 reasons, which are reliable and economical. Firstly, the exercises from the application are suitable according to the level of proficiency which is reliable. There are a lot of exercises from this application that suitable to the learners. The contents of the exercises are varieties and this will give fun for the learners to try and answer those exercises especially to the children because the topics are interesting and meets the new world right now. Some of the subtopics provide pictures to attract the attention of the learners. Secondly, this application is very economical because there is no need to pay any fees to visit this website. Anybody can visit it at any time for free. It is very economical yet reliable. With these 2 concrete reasons, I would definitely use this application in the future.

9. Suggestions/ Recommendations.
The application of Activities For ESL Students can be more fun to use by learners if the website is colorful with images and the addition of upgrading the system to the topic of pronunciation. Firstly, more colorful background and the used of interesting pictures and images are highly recommended. Children love to see something that is colorful and cheerful and if the website gives more interesting and attracting images or objects, it will motivate the learners to use the application as well as gain something by learning the language from it. Secondly, the topic of pronunciation is very important in learning the target language. Even though the application provides the topic of pronunciation that the learners can access to increase their fluency for the language but it is a little bit complicated to access to that section because the page could not be open. The application should be upgraded so that the learners are not going to have the difficulties in learning the pronunciation of the target language. By having this topic to part of the topic selections, the learners will know how to pronounce the certain words correctly hence, increase their fluency for the language. When the learners know how articulate the words correctly, they are able to communicate with others using the target language properly.

2 comments: